I wore these Brooks Sherpa 5-inch 2-in-1 Shorts for plenty of long runs, which is where I think their 2-in-1 design excels.
Men’s Fitness verdict
The Sherpa 5-inch version is a versatile 2-in-1 running short. It’s loose and breathable and with decent coverage and comfort too. Ideal for longer training miles and post-run cafe stops.- Wide, flat waistband
- Decent storage
- Hybrid design adds to versatility
- Heavier than some
- Items can bounce around in drop-in pockets
A longer, 5-inch version of Brooks classic race-fit 3-inch Sherpa split running shorts, these 2-in-1 shorts pair the same silky, lightweight four-way stretchy shell outer with a perforated inner short that drops lower down the leg. They’re one of the best running shorts I have tested.
Why you can trust Men’s Fitness
At Men’s Fitness we pride ourselves on delivering information that serves a singular purpose: to improve some aspect of your health, fitness or wellbeing. For almost 20 years, we’ve been publishing authoritative health and fitness content – written by our expert editors and contributors. We spend hours testing every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. The Brooks Sherpa 5-inch 2-in-1 Shorts were tried and tested by experienced run product tester Kieran Alger. Find out more about how we test.
Brooks Sherpa 5-inch 2-in-1 Short design
A bit more like a twin trail short, these soft, comfortable, sweat-wicking liners have flat seams that are friendly to your delicates. Hundreds of perforations also help keep things airy and cool down there. During my test runs I never felt like I was overheating, despite that double layer of fabric.
The hybrid design really ramps up the versatility, too. You get the best of both worlds in shorts that hang light, loose and racy but offer a bit more coverage and comfort, ideal for longer training miles and post-run cafe stops.
Brooks Sherpa 5-inch 2-in-1 Short features
If, like me, you like a wider waistband that puts far less pressure on your paunch, these have the biggest on test. It also has a pleasantly soft lining and oversized drawcords make it easy to tweak the fit or to tie even with gloves.
Storage is good with two identical large drop-in rear mesh pockets just below the waistband. Both will hold a large smartphone, or if you run without your phone there’s room for four or five gels plus some other small running essentials.
However, stashed items don’t sit entirely bounce-free when you’re moving at full pelt, and because they’re open pockets, there’s a risk that things can spill out. One does have a handy elastic loop for securing keys, though, and there’s another smartphone-size zippered pocket offering more security.
The Brooks Sherpa 5-inch shorts come in eight colours and prints and six sizes from XS to XXL.
Brooks Sherpa 5-inch 2-in-1 Shorts verdict
During my tests I found the combination of 2-in-1 support, a wide, soft waistband and high levels of ventilation extremely comfortable. The 5-inch versions have plenty of coverage, making them a versatile option for wearing post-run. The shorts have an array of storage options, though only one pocket that can be zipped shut. There are plenty of color and size options, too, and now the shorts are reduced online they represent even better value for money. If you want running shorts for long days on the trail, I don’t think you can get much better than these 5-inch Sherpas.
Brooks Sherpa 5-inch 2-in-1 shorts technical specs
| Details | Integrated boxer liner, flat waistband, 4-way stretch fabric, 3 pockets with key loop |
| Sizes | XS – 2XL |
| Colors | 10 colours available |
How we test the best running shorts
Our reviewers tested each pair of running shorts over a wide range of distances – from 5km to half-marathon – and during treadmill and outdoor training sessions as well as competitive events, to bring you the best of the best.
